Showing posts with label Chris Chatterton. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chris Chatterton. Show all posts

Friday, 23 May 2014

Day 182: The Ice Warriors THREE

In general, when I write this blog, I'll search for themes within the episode to discuss, such as which characters are interesting, how the direction is different or key elements within the plot. And one of the key plot strands within this story became quite pertinent to my day today. It wasn't that Martians decided to invade my Optics lecture, it was something far more mundane than that.

In real life, I'm in the process of studying for a degree in Physics. This involves regular laboratory sessions, some of which are computer based. These computer sessions will typically involve writing computer code to solve certain problems, and they can range from simple data entry to things that are supremely annoying. Today, I had a Special Relativity computer lab, which consisted of 8 young men taking it in turns to either shout loudly, swear, or place their heads in their hands out of sheer desperation. It's due to computers, which are wonderful things, but also somewhat temperamental. You can give them orders, but you have to do it in the right way and make sure that everything that you're doing is right, otherwise everything will go wrong.

It's a similar scenario that the Doctor faces in this story. He's offered the option of a computer but turns it down, preferring a pen and paper instead. Some of you who are reading this will think that this represents the Doctor being a Luddite, and rejecting technology in favour of the old ways of doing things, but in my mind, it made perfect sense. Because whilst computers can be useful, they can also be annoying, and there are also tiny subtelties that you can't always get when using a computer over working it out with pen and paper, like how the actual processes work so that you don't just know what the right answer is, but you also know how you got there and gained a greater appreciation of the science behind it.

I may have railed against the writer of this story for featuring some bad science a couple of days ago, but here it feels like one of the more accurate depictions of science that I've seen for a while.

Thursday, 22 May 2014

Day 181: The Ice Warriors TWO

One of the most interesting characters that we meet in this story is Clent. He's the leader of the group, and prone to barking orders at anyone who'll take them, constantly checking with the computer before making any judgment, in order to get the best possible scenario for his team. However, in doing so he is blind to the other needs of his crew, and their need to do things in a different manner, such as Penley, one of his former scientists, who left the group because he was restricted by the methods that Clent was forcing upon him. Arden (another scientist) states of Clent that "he's not a proper scientist, he's an organiser. He should've been born a robot." He represents the things that restrict the world, the people who come along and organise things so that they all work in a manner that suits them. And it's appropriate that he should come across the Second Doctor, as he's the Doctor who looks at this sort of thing and brings it down (cf The Macra Terror), and indeed in any other story, Clent would be the main villain. But here, we've got other things to contend with.